Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert

The human spirit craves adventure, and those brave enough to journey beyond the comforts of mainstream society to experience the natural world are often rewarded with memories that last a lifetime. Sometimes, however, these risks may prove to be far too great, and the results can be deadly.

For one California adventurer, the call of the wild led him on a perilous journey through the Utah wilderness that he hoped would become the greatest adventure of his life. He was right, but not nearly in the way he expected to be…

Everett Ruess was born in March of 1914 in Oakland, California as the second child to parents Christopher, a probation officer, and Stella, an artist and poet.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert

 

From a young age, Christopher challenged his son to read heavily and encouraged him to study the great philosophers. Everett later began to write poetry himself, and he even took up archery.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
erenow

But it was adventure that became Everett’s true passion, and he began showing an appetite for it as early as 1930 when he was just 16 years old. During that summer, Everett hitchhiked from Oakland to the town of Carmel-By-The-Sea, an impressive 100-mile journey.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
Halfway Anywhere

The following year, after graduating from Hollywood High School, Everett purchased a burro and set out on his first major expedition. Over the course of ten months, Everett would come to see iconic locations like the Grand Canyon and Zion National Park.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
Conde Nast / DOI

Not only was this trek an ambitious one, but it also set the foundation for the adventures Everett would seek out in the years to come. Unbeknownst to the young explorer, however, his next expedition would change everything…

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert

In November of 1934, 20-year-old Everett Ruess rode into the remote Utah township of Escalante accompanied by two pack burros. A settlement founded by Mormons in 1876, Escalante was a place where the arrival of a stranger was a rarity.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert

Everett made his camp just north of the town, pitching his tent in a sunbaked area along the Escalante River that was perfect for mid-day naps. The townspeople visited Everett often, making small talk and giving the friendly adventurer the lay of the land.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
The Salt Lake Tribune

The children of Escalante took a particular shine to Everett, and during his time there he took them riding and even treated them to a movie. After spending a few nights in town, Everett packed his burros and disappeared into the wilds of Utah. He was never heard from again.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
The New York Times

So what happened to the young explorer? Well, in 1999 David Roberts, an adventure writer for National Geographic Magazine, sought to find an answer to the 65-year-old mystery. The first stop on his investigation? Escalante.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
REI

After arriving in town, Roberts sat down with 74-year-old Norm Christensen, one of the children charmed by Everett during his stay in Escalante in 1934. Norm, who was only 10 at the time, was one of the last people to see Everett Ruess alive.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
erenow

According to Norm, Everett set off into the Utah desert after leaving Escalante, traveling southeast along the Hole in the Rock trail. This historic route had been plotted by 19th-century Mormon settlers and was a tried-and-true passageway for navigating the desert. Or so they believed.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
The Durango Herald

Roberts also spoke to a 91-year-old man while in Escalante named Melvin Alvey, who met Everett during his stay in town all those years ago. Melvin wasn’t surprised that Everett had disappeared, as even then he believed that the young man was ill-equipped to survive the harsh winter climate of the Utah desert.

However, historical reports show that Everett was still alive at least a week after leaving Escalante, having traveled 50 miles through the desert. We know that he came across two shepherds and some cattlemen, but after that, he simply vanished.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
High Country News

Despite Everett’s disappearance, red flags weren’t raised until almost three months later. This wasn’t out of the ordinary, though, as Everett had sent a letter to his family weeks earlier saying that his journey would likely prevent him from communicating for a month or two.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
SassafrasLaneVillage / Etsy

But when the letters Christopher and Stella sent to Marble Canyon, Arizona — the place where Everett was expected to re-emerge into civilization — were returned unopened, they quickly grew concerned. After contacting the postmistress, a search party was dispatched from Escalante in March of 1935.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
erenow

Eventually, the same two shepherds that had crossed paths with Ruess the previous November stumbled upon an old campsite in a steep-sided canyon known as Davis Gulch. Although Everett’s burros were found alive — albeit severely malnourished — there was no sign of the young explorer, his diary, or his camping gear.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
While no traces of Ruess were found, it was widely believed that he was murdered while trekking through the desert. More specifically, the group of cattlemen — who were the last to see him alive — were the supposed culprits behind Everett’s disappearance.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
Canyon Country Guide

In fact, Norm Christensen revealed that one of the cattlemen, a man by the name of Keith Riddle, had confessed to Everett’s murder. However, Riddle died in 1984 and no definitive evidence was ever found that pinned him to the crime.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
But in 2008, 74 years after Everett’s disappearance, a tip from a Navajo who claimed to have witnessed Everett’s murder led a man named Denny Bellson to the skeletal remains of a body at Comb Ridge. The bones — found in a crevice 60 miles from Everett’s last camp — were tested against the DNA of Everett’s nieces and nephews. It was a match!

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
The Durango Herald / Only in Your State

Heartbreakingly, however, it was later discovered that the DNA test had been botched and that the Comb Ridge remains belonged to a Native American. And so, the truth behind Everett Ruess’ disappearance still remains a mystery to this day.

Cold Case Takes A Wild Turn After New Tip Leads Investigators To The Desert
High Country News

What do you think happened to Everett Ruess?

Share this unsolved mystery with your friends below!

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

As hard as the police and FBI try to solve every case, it’s impossible not to make mistakes from time to time. They’re only human, and sometimes there are so many moving parts it’s difficult to find the answer.

When a one-day-old baby was stolen out of a hospital in Chicago, police and the FBI went on a manhunt to locate him. Then, two years later, they miraculously found him and returned him to his parents. However, not all was as it seemed…


In Chicago, 1964, Paul Fronczak was only one day old when he was stolen from the Michael Reese Hospital by a woman posing as a nurse. Paul’s mother, Dora, handed her newborn son off to the woman, and she left the room, never to return.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

Immediately, a citywide manhunt was launched. About 175,000 postal workers, 200 police officers, and the entire FBI scoured every inch of Chicago, but Paul was nowhere to be found. Would Dora and her husband, Chester, ever see Paul again?

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity
The worried parents tried to wait patiently for some kind of break in the case, but to their dismay, it seemed like Paul was gone for good. But, two years after the horrific kidnapping, the Fronczaks received a call…

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

It was the FBI, and they told Paul’s parents they located a boy in Newark, New Jersey who matched their son’s description! Dora and Chester were elated, but, was it too good to be true? Had they really found Paul after all this time?
Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

Dora and Chester drove from Chicago to Newark to finally reunite with their son who was now a toddler. No one, including the FBI, could believe the stroke of luck. However, this was far from the end of Paul’s journey.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

As Paul grew up, he learned about the whole kidnapping ordeal that occurred when he was a newborn. It was then that he started having some questions of his own…

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

You see, ever since he was returned to his parents, Paul hadn’t been able to shake the story of his past. It made him feel like an outsider, even within his own family unit.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

To compensate for these feelings Paul became super outgoing, listened to loud music, and started cruising on motorcycles. He was just trying to find himself, but this made him feel like even more of an outcast.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

A voice inside Paul wouldn’t be silenced. He couldn’t help it, he knew something wasn’t right in his life and he believed it all connected to his kidnapping. For one thing, he couldn’t understand why he had been found so far from Chicago…

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

Paul knew that unearthing the details surrounding his kidnapping would be stressful to his parents, but he also knew that doing some digging might help him feel more at home in the world. As an adult, Paul finally decided to face his fears and truly investigate his past.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

One afternoon in 2012 while his parents were visiting, Paul asked them to do a DNA swab test. He figured it would be best make sure that he really was who he thought he was. He sent out the samples, and several days later received the results via phone…

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

The person on the other end of the line told Paul there was “no remote possibility” he was Dora and Chester’s biological son! His world was just turned upside down, and he had no idea how to fix it.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

Who were his real parents if not Dora and Chester? Also, what happened to the real Paul Fronczak? Shocked themselves, the people Paul called his parents stood by his side in the face of this news. They helped Paul find a team of volunteers to help him get more answers.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

These “DNA Detectives” started a deep dive into Paul’s history, and traced his roots to Tennessee, where he was born into a Jewish family. Paul also learned his birth name was Jack Rosenthal. Now that he had a solid foundation, it was time to meet some relatives.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity
When Paul finally met one cousin Lenny, they immediately connected. Paul finally felt like he was with family. However, as great as Lenny was, Paul also learned about a dark side of his biological relatives…

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

Paul’s mother was an alcoholic and his father had severe anger problems. He also had a twin sister and siblings, but according to his family, the kids were all badly neglected. Paul had a strong suspicion something sinister may have happened to his twin sister, Jill, and that’s why his parents gave him up.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

Paul wrote a book about his entire journey working towards the truth called The Foundling. In it, he even talked about how he went to his parent’s old home and dug up the garden, hoping to find the remains of his sister. However, he had no such luck.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

After his book came out, Paul began giving interviews to people who wanted to know his whole bizarre story. His life had so many twists and turns, but Paul had at least uncovered some of the truth. But, his search is far from over…

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

To this day, Paul is still on the hunt for the actual Paul Fronczak who was abducted from his adopted parents. He is determined to give closure to a case that’s been following him ever since he was a toddler.

Decades After A Stolen Child Was Reunited With His Family, Questions Arose About His True Identity

It was truly amazing that the DNA Detectives were able to shed so much light on a life Paul Fronczak knew absolutely nothing about. Hopefully, he eventually finds closure for everything that’s happened.

If the real Paul Fronczak is still out there somewhere, here’s hoping he is one day found.

Share this unpredictable missing person case with your friends below!

Crawl Space Behind Grandma’s Dresser Holds The Key To Solving 2-Year-Old Missing Person’s Case

Crawl Space Behind Grandma’s Dresser Holds The Key To Solving 2-Year-Old Missing Person’s Case

It’s horrible to think about, but children go missing all the time. Police do their best to locate them, but not every missing child case gets solved. All anyone wants is some kind of closure, even if it takes years to get it. When a young boy from Illinois went missing in 2004, his father, … Read more

Weird Satellite-Like Mass Orbiting Earth Has Scientist Perplexed About Its Real Origins

Weird Satellite-Like Mass Orbiting Earth Has Scientist Perplexed About Its Real Origins

Whenever a situation is shrouded in mystery, it’s only a matter of time before people begin spewing conspiracy theories. The terrorist attacks on September 11, the assassination of John F. Kennedy, and even NASA’s moon landing are all ripe with conspiracies. While the events mentioned above are well known, there are plenty of strange theories … Read more